Preword: Before reading on, please disregard all past calls for a favorable pattern change and good December in recent days. Those prospects are not likely now.
I was one of the first to call for it, and now am one of many beginning to rethink calls for a pattern change. In fact, I'm outright canceling any of my hopes of a more favorable pattern after mid December, and here's why.
This is a short range forecast of the 500mb height anomalies in the atmosphere from the ECMWF Ensemble system. The current pattern has a high pressure system stuck over the Bering Sea into the western Gulf of Alaska. In response to this, we see all the cold and storminess stuck over western and central Canada, with only the Plains benefitting from this. We are also seeing high pressure systems then developing over the East and Central US regions.
That high pressure system over the Bering Sea kind of acts as if you had a piece of string being held up by two vertical structures. This Bering sea ridge of high pressure is one of these 'vertical structures', and the other one is off the Canadian Maritimes. The middle of the 'string' holds the cold and snow, and because those two 'vertical structures' are in place, this 'string' cannot move south and deliver winter-like weather to the States.
Many were calling for a big pattern change around Mid December which would supposedly get us into the real winter pattern we were waiting for and had been denied of last year. Well, here's the new pattern.
This new pattern features some changes. Going back to that string idea, we how have those 'vertical structures' further south, allowing the West US and Rockies to get in on the cold and storminess. This also opens the door for an enhanced storm track over the entire nation. The Bering Sea ridge had prevented such a stormy pattern, and thanks to this new pattern, that problem is gone.
But we have another problem-- the Pacific North American index, or the PNA index.
The PNA's territory is off the West Coast and in the Northeast Pacific. In short, whatever weather happens in the West US, the opposite is observed in the East. So, if we saw a ridge of high pressure in the West, the PNA would be positive and the East would see cool and stormy weather. The negative PNA gives the storms to the West and the warmth to the East.
Multiple forecasts from multiple models and ensemble groups show a definitive negative PNA setting up until at least December 20th. The ECMWF Ensembles show this as well, with the blue areas of below normal pressure sitting over the West US, and suddenly we have a persistent negative PNA. The bottom two images, one being the PNA forecast from the ESRL/PSD and the other forecast from the NCEP. I feel that the NCEP forecast is actually going to turn out good on this one, and the ESRL/PSD may not be the correct forecast this time around.
And just like that, the East gets the short end of the stick, while the West benefits greatly, especially in skiing resorts.
In case anyone's wondering, the North Atlantic Oscillation (NAO) stays neutral-ish around this forecast period, not really benefitting anyone and not trying to demolish the negative PNA.
What this means for the East is that we will still see very unseasonably warm temperatures, off and on. Thanks to the cold and storms now favoring the Rockies, it is probable that these systems will push east and give the rest of the nation a break from warm weather before it gets going again. The polar vortex (a.k.a. the Arctic Oscillation (AO)) looks to be stronger than normal, and you know what that means- enhanced probabilities of warm weather, nationwide.
Andrew
21 comments:
O man you've got to be joking please tell me you are! How could this be everything seemed to be coming together in the near future? Honestly Andrew I don't think you should throw in the towel just yet it's early. Their is got to be a change from last winter I can't go through another winter like last year. It was so depressing with no snow! Please is their any hope?
Sorry Andrew! Why is it you are the only one making this forecast when others are saying cold air dips down into the United State including the East. Take a look at the East coast future forecast. Are you trained in this area? Or is this a hobby?
Andrew, what you say this means for Iowa in terms of precipitation?
Definitely more than in recent weeks.
December is only one month of 3, and is usually the one with the most volatile temperatures.
If you know what a negative PNA, neutral NAO and positively-trending AO means for the nation, you should know that what I'm saying about this continuing warm pattern should verify.
Anonymous #2
The East coast future forecast isn't forecasting a cold outbreak. Yes some areas will have a few cold days, but the overall pattern doesn't favor a sustained period of cold weather for the east. Trends are favoring a negative PNA which puts a ridge into the eastern half of the US. So until this pattern changes, there will be some cold periods but it will probably be short lived. I know Andrew isn't the only person calling for this forecast.
Andrew, I give you credit. Long range forecasting is very difficult. Situations like this are going to occur from time to time. I appreciate your hard work.
andrew this is starting to get a bit rediculous, just last week you said the setup for cold and snow was right around the corner and now this. this is the last time im falling for your long term analysis
Andrew I respect you're forecast but I have some info from NOAA PNA observation's that show that the PNA should be negative for a bit. Does'nt this man that the East will be cold, or it will be on and off cold periods?
Then it'll probably be the last time you fall for anyone's analysis- what I'm showing will have the effects I am predicting, and those who were also predicting a good pattern change should start to see the things I'm seeing and say 'uh oh'.
Those on here who are ripping on Andrew on his long term forecasts need to cut it out! He is only the messenger!!!!!!!! Things change with the weather all of the time.
dont bother giving long range forcasts because they are never right lets just take it one week at a time
hey dude a negative pna can actually favor the midwest. especially with a negative epo in effect. while the east does get the "short end of the stick", the midwest does get benefit as the trough axis can actually cause storms to shoot up the jetstream coming out of the trough, making for a lot of snowstorms. so not all hope is lost :).
@ Anonymous 5 - Andrew puts HIS OWN time into this to let us know about weather, mainly long range. Why even bother coming here then? Also, weather is constantly changing, if you are looking at long range forecasts, you should know that...
@ Anonymous 7 - Long range forecasts can give you a general idea of what is to come, which is what I personally like to see.
But, I do not know Andrew, but it seems like he likes that to, so why should he stop because it isn't exactly right (even forecasts one week away aren't)
My last comment for the night - Andrew, I love that you do long range forecasts, none of my local meteorologists do them, and you give me something to see a general idea of what could be going on in the long range.
Thank you very much for your hard work. I will keep following you, like you on FB, etc., even if none of your long range forecasts are exact.
Just started following your blog . bummer on the warm winters but, what's an individual to do? Glad to have your informative insight. Blog is great :-), if sad about the warm winters :(. Keep up the good work!
Hi im 11 and I would like to know more about the ice threat for the possible Winter Storm around Christmas. I live in Danville, VA
YES!!! finally, a pattern that doesn't screw us over in Colorado and the Rockies/ Southwest, we so desperately need that moisture, good to hear some good news for a change.
Andrew, did you even look at the NAO forecast by the NWS? ALL of the ensembles have the NAO going negative by -2 before Dec. 16. AO is dropping the same time too. If this were to verify, the Midwest or East would be in seriously cold weather mid December.
Last anonymous: You cannot put all your eggs in one set of ensemble members. Besides, sure the NAO will be going negative, but if the PNA is negative enough, it'll just be periodic cold shots.
Post a Comment