Thursday, March 13, 2014

March 26-31 Multiple Potentially Significant Snowstorms

I'm examining the idea of multiple significant winter storms over the March 26-31 period.

The above image shows a recent ECMWF forecast, projecting 500mb height anomalies over the North Pacific on March 20th, where blues and purples show negative height anomalies (cool and stormy weather), and oranges and reds depict positive height anomalies (warm and quiet weather). Looking towards the continent of Asia, specifically zeroing in on Japan, I marked two points of interest using the letter X. These X's denote the location of storm systems in the area. There is a storm system moving east over Japan, tilting negatively as it does so, and a storm to the west of Japan, just beginning to drop south and racing towards the country. There is a rule, well explained by Joe Renken, that states a weather phenomenon in East Asia will be reciprocated in the United States 6-10 days later. This means that if there is a storm system in Japan on a certain day, we can expect a storm in the US 6-10 days after that. The same goes for high pressure and warm weather. The two storm systems both retain impressive intensities, with the bright purples indicating that both systems look to be strong.

About 18 hours later, we see that the situation over Japan has changed. The first storm system that was previously over Japan has shot north, influenced by the even-stronger system shown in green shades south of far northeast Russia. The second storm system that was previously racing towards Japan is now impacting Japan, maintaining rather-strong characteristics, as shown by the tinted purples over the country. This confirms there may be not one, but two storm systems in this timeframe.

Shown above is the ECMWF Ensemble mean forecast of 500mb height anomalies, over North America. The same color rules, where blues indicate stormy weather and oranges show calm weather, still apply. This forecast is valid on March 26th, the beginning of the five day period we're watching for these two potential storms. We see storminess evolving over the West Coast, shown by the darker blues just offshore of California, Oregon and Washington state. We see this provoking slight ridging in the southern Plains, well illustrated by the erosion of blues in that region. We also see an old friend in a piece of the polar vortex still sticking around in Canada. The storminess over the West Coast should enable the high pressure over the Southern Plains to gradually strengthen and push east, as it's possible we see a negative Pacific-North American pattern evolve, which is characterized in the image below.

Typical negative PNA pattern
NCSU
We also see how a lobe of the polar vortex still sits over Canada, as it has been doing for much of the winter, and should continue to do into spring. If this forecast were to verify, it wouldn't be too hard for the storm track to be suppressed, from the Midwest down into the Ohio Valley. This could favor areas that have been hit multiple times already this winter, including the lower Midwest and Ohio Valley regions.

The GFS Ensemble forecast for 500mb anomalies at about the same timeframe have a pretty similar pattern, even though they may seem different at first glance. The PNA remains negative, like the ECMWF ensembles project, as we see strong negative height anomalies over the West Coast. We also see a lobe of the polar vortex positioned in Canada, as we did in the ECMWF Ensemble image. The only 'difference' here is that the ridge we discussed in the ECMWF Ensemble image is more pronounced on this image, and located further east. This solution would likely still drive storm systems into the Midwest, but they would also be suppressed- just not as much as the ECMWF ensembles say they would be. This sort of projection would take the two potentially significant snowstorms into the Midwest and Ohio Valley, as ridging in the Southeast would deter an East Coast solution.

Caveat: The ECMWF projection that says we would get two major storm systems is a long range forecast, and has a chance of not verifying completely. There is a pretty good chance we would be seeing a potentially significant storm system in this timeframe, it's the idea of two storm systems instead of one that isn't really solidified just yet.

To summarize:
-One or possibly two potentially significant storm systems are expected in the March 26-31 timeframe.
-Both winter and severe weather modes would be quite possible with this event.

Andrew

March 22-26 Potential Weak Storm System

There's the potential for a weak storm system in the March 22-26 timeframe.

WeatherBell
It's looking like we'll be seeing a storm system cut across Japan on March 16th, with rather meager negative height anomalies, indicating a weak storm system. There is a rule, well explained by Joe Renken, that states a weather phenomenon in East Asia will be reciprocated in the United States 6-10 days later. This means that if there is a storm system in Japan on a certain day, we can expect a storm in the US 6-10 days after that. The same goes for high pressure and warm weather. Thus, 6-10 days after the date where we see a storm hit Japan (March 16) brings us to a potential storm system in the US around the March time period.



Looking deeper into that ECMWF forecast, we see strong high pressure over the West Coast. This is strongly indicative of a positive Pacific-North American pattern (positive PNA), which is demonstrated in the above graphic. The positive phase of the PNA sees high pressure form over the West Coast, which then leads to storminess and cold weather in the Plains. This sort of pattern can give snow to the Midwest and Ohio Valley in situations where ridging tries to push north in the Southeast, but can also send wintry weather to the East Coast if we see high pressure over Greenland.

WeatherBell
If we go out in the long range, we can see what the weather pattern may be like on March 22nd, the first day of this window that has been designated for a storm system. We see that the pattern includes warm weather in the West, as persistent ridging continues, but also pushes east into the Plains. More importantly is the presence of a piece of the polar vortex digging well into the Northeast, likely providing the chance for another intense round of cold weather. This sort of pattern tells me we would likely see some severe weather in the South Plains, but that would be about it. This pattern isn't conducive for wintry weather in the Plains, Midwest or Ohio Valley, and the polar vortex will be suppressing the storm south to likely keep it away from the East Coast.

This looks to be a weak storm, and impacts should be minimal on the wintry side. I would monitor severe weather prospects in the near future, however.

Andrew

Wednesday, March 12, 2014

March 20-24 Potential Storm System

I'm watching out for a potential storm system around the March 20-24 timeframe.


WeatherBell
There is a rule, well explained by Joe Renken, that states a weather phenomenon in East Asia will be reciprocated in the United States 6-10 days later. This means that if there is a storm system in Japan on a certain day, we can expect a storm in the US 6-10 days after that. The same goes for high pressure and warm weather. Using the image above, we can expect a storm in the US 6-10 days after March 14th, which would bring us to a March 20-24 storm. 

The storm looks pretty healthy in this model projection, which could also mean we see some active weather, both in terms of severe and wintry weather. It's still too far out to tell who could get hit, but considering we'll be seeing the Madden-Julian Oscillation in Phase 2 around this timeframe, I would keep an eye out for severe weather.

(The following is copied from the March 4th post)

Paul Roundy
Shown above is a chart of six different types of outgoing long wave radiation (OLR) anomalies. We want to focus on the middle panel of the left-hand side, where it says MJO OLR anomaly on February 16, 2014. On February 16, 2014, we saw negative OLR anomalies just south and east of the subcontinent of India. This location of the -OLR anomalies (which indicate enhanced tropical convection) tells us the Madden-Julian Oscillation was in Phase 2, out of its 8 possible phases. Check out the severe weather event that occurred just four days later, on February 20, 2014.


On February 20, 2014, we saw a large-scale severe weather outbreak, as the chart of storm reports from the Storm Prediction Center shows above. The outbreak was primarily a damaging wind event, as you can see by the large swath of blues across Tennessee and Kentucky, just to name a few of the many affected states. However, we also saw a handful of tornado reports. The fact of the matter is, this severe weather event and the MJO entering Phase 2 are not coincidence. They are correlated with one another. See the AMS (American Meteorological Society) article below:

The Madden–Julian oscillation (MJO) has been linked to weather variability in the midlatitudes via its associated overturning circulations and Rossby wave trains that redistribute the thermal and mass fields at higher latitudes. This work examines the relationship between the MJO and violent tornado outbreaks in the United States. A census of events shows that violent tornado outbreaks during March–April–May (MAM) are more than twice as frequent during phase 2 of the Real-time Multivariate MJO (RMM) index as during other phases or when the MJO was deemed inactive.

If you didn't get what this was saying, don't worry. Basically, it tells us that when the MJO is in Phase 2 during March, April and May, or when we see enhanced convection south and southeast of India, we tend to see the chances of a violent tornado outbreak skyrocket in comparison to the nonactive MJO, or the MJO in other phases. While the February 20th event wasn't exactly a tornado outbreak, it was a severe weather event, and this has me concerned for mid-March.


Let's take a look at the forecasted OLR anomalies for March 12, 2014. Once again, we'll look towards the panel labeled MJO OLR Anomaly. If we look at the forecast by Paul Roundy above, we can see very deep negative OLR anomalies placed just south and southeast of India. These blues are far deeper than what we saw on February 16, meaning that this Phase 2 MJO event could be even stronger, and thus the severe weather event would be even stronger as well. Going by the LRC we discussed above, as well as the AMS document analyzed here, I am concerned that we will see a potentially significant severe weather outbreak for the mid-March period. Because there could be a lag period between the MJO Phase 2 event and the severe weather event of about 4 days, like we saw with the February event, I'll make a tentative timeframe of March 13-18 for a potential severe weather outbreak. This one has me worried, and while you should not be worried yet, it's something to watch out for in the future.

(End copied post)

If we come back to Paul Roundy's forecast and look at the MJO OLR Anomaly panel, it looks like the placement for Phase 2 anomalies has been pushed back to March 16, which would put the possible severe weather threat either just before or during this potential storm system. Lots of things to watch here.

Andrew

March 15-19 Potentially Significant Storm System

I'm eyeing the March 15-19 period for what could be a significant storm system.

The image above shows ECMWF 500mb height anomalies from a previous forecast, valid on March 9th, which was two days ago. While this forecast is not current, and the forecast image above is not current either, we did see a big storm move through Japan on March 9th. There is a rule, well explained by Joe Renken, that states a weather phenomenon in East Asia will be reciprocated in the United States 6-10 days later. This means that if there is a storm system in Japan on a certain day, we can expect a storm in the US 6-10 days after that. The same goes for high pressure and warm weather. Using the image above, we can expect a storm in the US 6-10 days after March 9th, which would bring us to a March 15-19 storm. Not only that, but this forecast indicates the storm in Japan will be/was strong when it passed through, and this means that the storm we experience March 15-19 could very well be strong, too.

Shown above is the latest ECMWF ensemble mean forecast for 500mb height anomalies on the evening of March 15th. Interestingly enough, we see the ECMWF ensembles already have this storm in the Plains, meaning the idea of a big winter storm for this timeframe is becoming popular. The ensembles have a positive PNA pattern in place, meaning we see high pressure shooting north along the West Coast, with consequential storminess in the Plains. We also see ever-so-slight ridging in the Southeast, but this is suppressed by the piece of the polar vortex displaced over southern Canada. It looks like the ensembles want to develop a split jet stream pattern, which could open the door for phasing of storm systems. Despite this potential, I feel that any storm in this timeframe would either move east and possibly up the coast, though I'm a bit hesitant about that potential due to the polar vortex pushing down on the jet stream as well as the storminess over Greenland (which typically does not favor East Coast snowstorms). The other idea would be the storm moving north and hitting the Midwest/Great Lakes, but I'm also skeptical on this idea due to the polar vortex piece trying to suppress the storm (which could very well happen), as well as the lack of high pressure in the Southeast to force the storm north. We'll get a much better handle on this in coming days, but be warned that the March 15-19 period could see a potentially significant storm hit the US.

It is also worth noting that we could see some severe weather, though to which degree is to be determined.

Andrew

Monday, March 10, 2014

Impending Snowstorm to Drop 12"+ of Snow Tuesday and Wednesday

Note: This post will concern the March 11-14 Significant Snowstorm, but the title has been changed. If you find this sort of title better than the date and storm classification, or if you prefer the date + classification, leave your input in the comments below.

I'm carefully watching the next few days for a snowstorm that looks to drop a foot of snow or more on the United States.

We'll begin with an analyzation of the big picture of this storm. The model I will be using here will be the NAM model, as its low-resolution GFS counterpart appears to be suffering from some errors we will address later on in this post. The image above shows mean sea level pressure (MSLP) values, as well as precipitation values and high and low-pressure demarcations for Tuesday afternoon, tomorrow. We see a strong storm system in the far northeast corner of Kansas, bottoming out at 994 millibars and creating a heck of a pressure gradient over Nebraska. In Nebraska, we also see a precipitation shield breaking out, which could be accompanied by some harsh winds if that pressure gradient happens to meet up with the precipitation. Luckily, this forecast keeps the strongest winds just south and east of the inclement weather in northwest Nebraska.

In the late evening hours of Tuesday, we see that our storm system has pushed off to the east, maintaining both its tight pressure gradient and precipitation shield as it progresses east. Our storm is now at about 995 millibars, roughly the same strength as what we saw Tuesday afternoon in the image above. The 1 millibar difference really isn't anything to write home about in this situation. Typically, we might see a severe weather situation arising in the Plains and Midwest due to that tight pressure gradient, but that swath of precipitation down in Mississippi, Alabama and the panhandle of Florida indicate there's a storm system there (a closed low, to be exact) that will prohibit such a severe weather event from forming. At this point in time, accumulating snow should begin to fall over the Midwest.

By the time we hit the morning of Wednesday, March 12, we find that phasing has occurred with our storm system. What this means is that our original system has phased, or merged, with a system coming south from Canada to create a single, stronger storm. This is clearly displayed by the abundant precipitation breaking out over Michigan, Indiana and Ohio, and also shown by the tighter pressure gradient expanded across much of the Central and East US. It is also possible the western flank of the gradient is a bit amplified thanks to the strong high pressure in Canada, but that's not a big piece of the puzzle right now. At this point in time, potentially significant accumulating snow looks to be impacting the Ohio Valley.

Lastly, by the evening hours of Wednesday, we see the system has now transferred offshore, and is now putting down significant accumulating snow across the interior Northeast, leaving coastal areas (and even some inland regions) to experience rain or a mixing event.  The extreme pressure gradient remains in place, maximized in this forecast graphic over Pennsylvania and New York, as well as the rest of the New England area. After this, the storm exits the region, leaving quite a snowstorm in its wake. Check out the latest snowfall forecasts for this event:

To add some model variety, we'll also show the GFS snowfall forecast.

If you look at these maps and think something's not the same, you're right. There are some differences here. The primary difference is that the GFS is more south with the storm system than the NAM model. This is displayed well when looking at the beginning of the accumulating snow swath all the way back out in Illinois. The NAM model gives a generous 6" or more to Chicagoland, but the GFS only lays down a handful of inches across Springfield, IL.

After looking at all the data, I think it might be best to lean towards a NAM solution with the placement of heavy snow further north in the Great Lakes, but not too far north, if you know what I mean. Let's go over why.

The first red flag is the NCEP Weather Prediction Center's preferred track superimposed on an ensemble suite for this storm system. We see the NCEP WPC track for this storm in black, but it's obvious that their track is on the southern envelope of guidance. The heavy majority of ensemble members prefer to take this storm further north, into central or northern Missouri rather than southwestern MO. This would result in snow totals displaced further to the north, like the NAM says. But we can dig deeper than this. Let's keep going in our search for why these northern amounts are more preferred over the GFS.

Let's take a close look at the image above. Here, we see the NAM model projecting 300mb wind speeds in color shades and wind barbs, valid early Wednesday morning. If you look closely, you can spot two distinct jet streaks, or two areas of stronger winds than the winds around them. These are shown best by the yellows in Oklahoma and Kansas, as well as in far northern New England. These two jet streams form the classic coupled jet stream, as defined by Uccellini and Kocin in their studies. This coupled jet stream idealizes that there is a space between two jet streaks, where heightened divergence is found. In other words, in the space between two jet streaks, the atmosphere wants to create more precipitation. So, if we look above for the space between these two jet streaks, we can draw a line roughly from Missouri to Lake Michigan of where this increased divergence, or increased precipitation would be expected to appear. This would seem to put the NAM's snowfall placement 'in the right' when compared to placement of the GFS snow totals, at least in the Great Lakes region.

Also, take a look at what the 18z GFS does with the storm as it moves along the Ohio Valley.


If you watch the low pressure denotation as it moves from Indiana, it goes to the southeast rather than to the east. You might not think this is so odd, but when you compare it to the agreed notion that this storm will be moving west-to-east, a southward movement is rather odd.

Additionally, a convective feedback issue was observed as the system crossed east through Indiana, likely hampering the forecast for this storm. In this case, you may want to defer to the 12z GFS, as it is more logical in comparison to this run.

To conclude, a significant winter storm is expected for a good chunk of the US. Model guidance differs on placement of the snow, mainly in the Great Lakes, but it is agreed on that the Northeast will see a substantial snowstorm.

Andrew