Thursday, December 13, 2012

Stormy Pattern Could Solidify, Watch For Cooling Trend Towards January

I think now is the time to seriously sit down and address what's likely to happen with the atmosphere in coming weeks and into the end of Dec.

I'd like to start off with the potential for slightly cooler temperatures emerging over the nation. Above is a chart of observed 70mb stratospheric temperatures from 2011 and 2012. The dashed green line is the average stratospheric temperature for that time of the year. Let's take a look on the right side of this chart, where the newest observations are in. See that spike in temperatures? That was a recent stratospheric warming event, known as a significant stratospheric warming event (SSW). An SSW shows that warm air has penetrated into this layer of the atmosphere, and is rapidly increasing the temperature, key word being rapidly, hence the 'sudden' in sudden stratospheric warming. I have learned that there is roughly a 10 day gap between an SSW and observed cold weather at the surface. Considering this cold air must push through several hundred millibars (several thousand feet) in the atmosphere, such a gap is not surprising. If we estimate that this SSW happened a few days ago (we'll say Dec. 8-10), one would expect a trend towards colder weather to occur near the 18th-20th. It is possible that this cold air arrives shortly after the departure of a potentially significant winter storm during this time period, but more forecasts are needed to confirm this.

Adding to the potential for a cooling trend towards January is the raggedness of the polar vortex. The top image shows pressure and temperature forecasts from the ECMWF model at 1 millibar- the highest integer you can get in the stratosphere. The bottom image is the same pressure and temperature forecast in the 100mb layer, considered the end of the stratosphere and the beginning of the troposphere. If you look closely at these images, you can see big capital 'L' symbols. That marks the position of the lowest pressure readings in that area, a.k.a. the Polar Vortex (PV). If you try to match up the two 'L's in these two images, you'll find that they are not near each other. This is equivalent to an uneven Jenga tower- the bottom blocks are more populous on one side, and the top blocks are plentiful on another side. If you play Jenga, you know that such a recipe spells a very unstable tower. In a similar sense, such a mismatched polar vortex means that the cold air that the PV holds onto is more able to be released south. If such a mismatched PV goes on for some more time, we could see a complete collapse of the vortex altogether, leading to frigid air across the board, but that's for another time.
Continuing to analyze the 100mb layer of the stratosphere, check out the light orange colors over North America. This means that the stratosphere is warm in that area. As we know, a warm stratosphere forces cold air south. If cold air is able to propagate south from the lower stratosphere, I see it more than plausible for a cold air mass to settle over Canada. The North Plains and Upper Midwest could also be involved. If a good storm system were to come along and hold onto some of that cold air, I see it possible for a sharp temperature crash in the North half of the US as a result of the warming of the stratosphere. If you are wondering how this could all perfectly happen, just ask Russia and Europe: They're experiencing a warm stratopshere, and currently suffering from extreme cold.

This is the Madden-Julian Oscillation (MJO) forecast from the ECMWF Ensembles. We can see that the forecast calls for the MJO moving into a weak Phase 1. Typically, such a phase is supportive of deep cold over the nation, but the negative PNA says otherwise (we will discuss this next). Anyhow, the lack of strength in this Phase 1 is not reassuring, I believe that the MJO will have little effect on the weather for some time, especially in part thanks to the negative PNA, which we will now discuss.

A mixed blessing. A double-edged sword. Only a few of the terms used to describe the negative PNA. On one hand, the negative phase of the Pacific North American index leads to storms in the West, which can then transfer energy across the Rockies and into the East. On the other hand, a depressed height anomalies in the West also translate into raised height anomalies in the East in a typical equal-and-opposite-reaction example. Today's 12z suite of models and ensembles reaffirms my thoughts of the negative PNA sitting in place for a while, but a positive PNA could emerge later on. But this time, many may not want to see this factor switch back to positive. The negative PNA looks to be composed of multiple strong pieces of energy that are pushing into the West Coast. As this happens, they swing into the Southwest and through the South Plains, and, depending on other atmospheric factors, can go into the Plains, Midwest and East Coast. The negative PNA tends to divert storm tracks into the Plains and down through the Gulf Coast, hence the recent snowstorms in the Upper Midwest/North Plains. But the latter storm track will be falling into place soon. As we see some pieces of energy start to follow that Gulf Coast track, a negative NAO will pick it up and try (most likely succeed) in picking up the storms, shooting them up the coast, and bombing out into the (in)famous Nor'easter.

12z models and ensembles forecasting the NAO show a good consensus with a weak negative NAO eventually pushing into a moderate negative NAO before some signs of a backtrack into a weak negative NAO occur. Note the GFS ENS/GFS/GGEM ENS showing the NAO trending into neutral territory. Before you get upset, New Englanders, this will also be the time when the PNA may go positive, so that Gulf Coast track wouldn't be present anyhow.

The North Atlantic Oscillation is a little more complicated than just positive and negative. When the high pressure system that causes the negative NAO is west of Greenland, we call that a west-based negative NAO (for obvious reasons). Likewise, the ridge being east of Greenland results in an east-based negative NAO.

This is the same 12z model suite forecast, now for the west-based negative NAO. Notice how all models and ensembles are pushing heavily on a deep negative west-based (WB) negative NAO, before trending into neutral territory in the long range. The effects of a west-based negative NAO include that storm track being shoved into a position that favors more coastal storms, something many in the East Coast are looking forward to. Cold air is also realigned in a pattern that favors chilly days in the East US.

Let's take a step back and regroup all of this information. We have the PNA going negative, which will incite pieces of energy moving into the Gulf Coast. We have a negative NAO that will then take these pieces of energy and move them up the coast. The tendency for a west-based negative NAO will then amplify these storms. Adding to the mix, the idea of a storm taking a quick detour north from the Southeast results in a trend towards a more meridional flow for the region, something that enhances the storm system and thus the precipitation. An example of this meridional flow is shown below:

8-10 day ECMWF 500mb height forecast. Possible
atmospheric pattern outlined in black. Note the
sharp detours and turns that happen as
the flow continues through the nation. This is
meridional flow.
Something else intriguing me is the sudden crash of the Southern Oscillation Index (SOI). You avid weather followers may know it as a predictor of the El Nino or La Nina, but it serves another purpose- showing Kelvin Waves.

The most recently taken observation of both observed underwater values and anomaly underwater values are shown above, with depth of the water on the left and location on the bottom. If you look in the upper left corner of the anomaly chart, you can see a blob of orange and yellow. The placement of this swath at 100m-150m underwater, as well as its tendency to be longer than taller, tells me that this is a Kelvin Wave. A Kelvin Wave is a warm body of water that moves along the equatorial Pacific between 50m-200m, and shows up as a blob of red. The presence of a Kelvin Wave forces the waters to warm, and warm waters means rising air (a.k.a. convection). This enhanced rising air as a result of the warm Kelvin Wave waters blows the bottom out of the SOI, hence why we have seen the index crash in daily observed values below.

Columns (from left to right): Date, two columns of observed pressures,
daily SOI values, 30 day averaged SOI values, 90 day averaged SOI values.
As I have recently learned, when this SOI crashes, the pattern then will try to regulate itself by enhancing cold weather over the North Hemisphere. And why, you ask? Because, as the warm air shoots into the atmosphere from the Kelvin Wave, the polar vortex is affected. Much like the SSW, the polar vortex is injected with warmer air, and the vortex weakens, releasing cold air south, possibly into the Lower 48. Now, I wouldn't nearly place all my money on this, considering the Kelvin Wave/SOI is one in dozens and dozens of atmospheric factors, but such an event could have interesting implications as we move towards January.

Well, there you have it folks. The pattern is looking stormier and cooler as we move through December and into January. As soon as the October correlation in Siberia cooperates, Jan/Feb are looking even chillier than all of this could do. Exciting times ahead.

I would like to thank the Severe Weather Centre, a fantastic weather blog not unlike mine, and the AccuWeather Forums for detailing some information used here.



Logan said...

None of my local meteorologists look at all of the oscillations and actual 'weather' like you do.
They only show us NAO forecast, and computer models... NOTHING ELSE EVER.

Also on the whole TWC thing, I think it is ridiculous for the storm:con thing... I can see people thinking: '6 not too bad, 4 from 10' - when they may mean 6 is real bad. And if 6 meant 60% like tor:con, when they forecast 5 inches and 2 feet of snow, both would be 10, both would be 10s, but one would be way worse...

Anyway, thanks for this post is all really :)

Anonymous said...

The storm for next week looks like the 20-22 now, and shows a 994mb low right over Chicago for next Friday. Might wanna update this too if you can, cause it could be at least a small-scale winter storm.

Anonymous said...

Really loving the posts Andrew it really entertains me and gives me hope! So can you make a post about the storm next week like the 20-22 timeframe? It looks epic for the mid atlantic/northeast as of right now. Thanks

Anonymous said...


Anonymous said...

Latest 12Z model data from the Euro is a little scary. This guy needs to update that now.

Anonymous said...