Tuesday, March 19, 2013

Palm Sunday 2013 Potential Winter Storm

There is indeed potential for a winter storm from March 23rd to March 25th.

We will do a model overview today. All models are forecasting Hour 144 (6 days away), and are showing 500 millibar heights in colors with sea level pressure in contour lines. To start, we will analyze the American GFS model. This model takes the storm into the southern tip of Lake Michigan at a minimum pressure of 992 millibars, considered pretty strong for an onshore storm system. Typically, storms will easily exceed that strength offshore in the Pacific or Atlantic, but close to 990 millibars onshore, while not infrequent, is relatively uncommon. Regardless, the storm system is taken through the Great Lakes, allowing significant snow to bury the Midwest and Great Lakes, upwards of one foot in many states west of Lake Michigan and into the Plains.

The general synopsis that is probable to happen is a storm system dropping from the northwest into the Plains, and then moving either east or northeast to bring winter weather to people in the north and severe weather to people in the south. The models are having trouble with grasping how far south the storm will end up dropping into the Plains and what direction the storm will head after encountering the high pressure in the Southeast and East US when the system is in the Plains.

We're going to move onto the foreign models now, and we start that part of this post with the Canadian model. Before I get into this model, know that it is notorious for being unreliable with storms and should not be trusted easily, no matter how amazing the solution is. The Canadian model has this storm system moving through south-central Illinois, dropping over half a foot in cities like Chicago, Gary, maybe even into Iowa (I haven't had an opportunity to see precipitation charts, just a few meteograms). The Canadian model drops this storm to 998 millibars, suprisingly weaker than the American model. The reason it is so surprising is because its usually the Canadian model over-exaggerating a storm's strength and not the other way around. Something to watch for the future? You bet.

We now go onto the United Kingdom's model. Because the phrase United Kingdom is too long to type every time I mention the model, I will refer to this forecasting system as the UKMET, its official model name. The UKMET sees this system weakly progressing in a track from Alabama to Ohio that would bring severe weather to the Southeast and snow to the southern Midwest. This is the weakest model yet of the three we have seen thus far, and its track is the third option of the three models. As you can already tell, the chances of figuring out a track for this system today are quite low.

The last of our foreign models is the European model. While it is typically regarded as the top forecasting model in the world as far as accuracy goes, I have been seeing a recent drop-off in its accuracy, and you may want to note that when taking this forecast into account. The European model doesn't show the system anywhere near the Midwest. If you look closely, you will see it off the coast of the Mid-Atlantic. It has cut across the South and prohibited any major snow event from occurring in the Midwest or Ohio Valley. While it is the fourth different solution from the four models we have seen, the European has been rather consistent with its idea of a storm system offshore the Carolinas for at least two runs. In the other models defense, the American GFS' idea of a major snow event in the Midwest, Great Lakes and Plains has been trending as well. Looks like the traditional American vs European model battle is setting up here, with the other foreign models just doing their own thing.

I did take a look at a few ensemble sets. Two ensemble sets, the American ensembles and another set called the North American Ensemble Forecasting System (NAEFS) are showing solutions that are very nearly identical. Because the NAEFS does not provide precipitation graphics on the website I used to evaluate these ensembles, I looked at the American ensembles for precipitation. The American ensembles predict a major snowstorm from the east central Plains into the Midwest and Great Lakes. Cities like St. Louis, Chicago, Milwaukee, Detroit and Gary would all be affected, many of them by pure snow. It is also worth noting that the Canadian ensembles and European ensembles keep the storm system further to the south. While the European ensembles cancel out a Midwest snowstorm altogether, the Canadian ensembles still throw a swath of accumulating snow at all of the aforementioned cities. Precipitation charts are not available on the European ensembles.

My current thoughts on this system are solid enough for me to show a swath of significant snow potential and a swath of severe weather potential. I am leaning towards the very weak model consensus that there will be the aforementioned types of weather in their respective regions. The red L's show where current model forecasts have this system, and as you can see, the consensus is loose at best.

Stay tuned to The Weather Centre for daily updates on this potential winter storm.


Logan said...

I'm right in between those.... D'oh!

Anonymous said...

Nice write up, but the Euro does indeed have a midwest snowstorm. look at hour 120..then it transfers that energy to the east by hour 144. Euro gives St. Louis easily 6+ inches of snow. Check it out on Wunderground.

Anonymous said...

I hope it misses! Keep us update please Andrew!
Thank you!

Andrew said...

Anonymous at 6:38: The source I was seeing showed nothing. Then again, they (WeatherBell) list the snowfall as 'derived', so you may be correct. Thanks for pointing It out.

Mark said...

Hi Andrew,
I am a student forecaster from Atlanta, GA, and I am 11 years old.
I really love your work on this site, so keep up the great work!
I also have a blog of my own, which is just getting started: usweatherplus.wordpress.com
Please visit the site, and comment how you like it. Also, comment on the blog if you would like to bceoma apart of its team, and forecast on it too.
Thank you,

Some more information about me:
I love weather. I enjoy tracking severe storms, and I would love to see a tornado. I also love to see lots of snow. I also play chess, and very well for my age, and hike all over the southeast, in the Smoky Mountains, and other mountains. Some trails I hike are up to 16 miles long!

Anonymous said...

Andrew looking at the temps for us here in southern va I don't think we'll get snow or severe weather. Do you thinkk there is a chance fore a wintry mix or severe weather for us? I beleive it will just be a rain event but if you have a different opinion please tell me!

Andrew said...

Mark: Nice blog! As you gather more information on why you are forecasting what, be sure to share it with the audience. People love it when you put your personal opinion into your work.

Southern VA Anonymous: Exact locations are still TBD.

Mark said...

Thank you, Andrew! Be sure to continue visit it, and check the latest updates from our team (currently me and 3 others)

Eric said...

Andrew, this storm reminds me a lot of March 28-29 storm of 1983, which looks very similar to the current situation in that there is an initial low pressure center over the Ohio Valley, which then is forced to transfer energy eastward towards the Atlantic coast under the prominent block towards eastern Canada. In that storm, there was a considerable amount of snow towards the Ohio Valley and areas of the northeast, with severe weather over the southeastern US in a very similar region, from Louisiana to the Carolinas, and with the transfer of energy to the coast underneath the block to the north, the "Bowling-ball" area of low pressure swung by to the north and with proper heating, focusing of lower heights near the low pressure and optimum wind shear, the most devastating tornado outbreak of the 20th century (would be later beat by April 16 2011) took place over NC. Interestingly, like what we are going to see over towards Arkansas and into Missouri for areas north of I-40, there was an abnormally large late season snowstorm into the south days before this storm in 1983 on March 24th, 1983 with snow into many areas of the south including Atlanta. Sounds very similar if you ask me.